BALCA does not allow Employer’s Recruitment Report to Contain Minor Discrepancies

In its decision In the Matter of Robert Bosch LLC, Case Number 2012-PER-01739, (8/25/2016), the Board of Alien Labor Certification Appeals (BALCA) affirmed a denial of an Application for Permanent Employment Certification when the employer’s recruitment report listed a total of 62 applications for the position received, when in fact there had only been 61. The argument by counsel and evidence submitted that a typographical error had omitted a consecutively numbered row in the recruitment chart which the employer used to track the total number of resumes received was not considered to be a harmless error. As the Board reasoned, the employer had failed to submit this evidence in the original audit response even though it was available and consideration of a corrected report was thus barred by the regulations.

Another harsh result after a lengthy process which the employer had begun in 2010 and which highlights again the importance of diligence by everyone involved in the process of presenting the results of a properly conducted recruitment campaign as part of the PERM labor certification.process.

The decision can be found here:

Recommended Posts
Contact Us

If you have a general comment, please leave us a message. For specific legal questions, you can request an appointment for an initial consultation either in person in our office, over the phone or via Skype.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt

Start typing and press Enter to search